The Role of Justice and Prudence in Rational Approbation and Disapprobation and Its Impact on The Formation of The Conducts of The Wise

Document Type : Original Article

Authors

Tehran University

Abstract

The analysis of the standpoints about the criteria of rational approbation and disapprobation gives two major criteria which are "general prudence or depravity" and "justice or oppression". Furthermore, the conducts of the wise are formed based on rational approbation and disapprobation. Considering the two major standpoints about the criterion of approbation and disapprobation, the question at hand is: what is the impact of each criterion on the formation of the conducts of the wise? Have Osuli scholars noticed the impressibility of the formation of the conducts of the wise from both of the criteria? Is there any sample of the conducts of the wise impressible from each of the criteria? Research in the sayings of Osuli scholars shows that they have paid attention to the role of rational approbation and disapprobation in the formation of the conducts of the wise and because of this attention, the theory of "the impossibility of the rejection of the conducts of the wise" is proposed. Nevertheless, most of Osuli scholars' attention is directed towards the role of the general prudence or depravity in the formation of the conducts of the wise. But there are many examples of the conducts of the wise that are impressible from rational approbation and disapprobation that is based on justice and oppression. Some of the rules of the penal codes and international human rights customs fall into this category.

Keywords

References

-Ansari, M. (2004). Matārih al-alnzār. Qom: Majma' al-fikr al-Islami.
-A'raji, A. (2002). Ishrāq al-Lāhūt fī naqd sharḥ al-Yāqūt. Tehran: Mirase Maktube Research Center.
-Astar Abadi, A. (2012). Sharḥ al-fosūl al-Nasiriah. Karbala: Al-'atabat al-Hosainiat al-Moghadasah.
-Borujerdi, H. (1995). Nihāyat al-osūl. Tehran: Tafakkor Publication.
-Fazile Miqdad, M. (1985). Irshād al-tālebin ela nahj al-mustarshedin. Qom: Public Library of Ayatullah Najafī Mar'ashi.
-Fazile Miqdad, M. (2001). Al-lawāmi' al-elāhiah fī al-mabāhith al-kalāmiah. Qom: Publications of Qom Islamic Propagation Offīce.
-Ibn Sina, H. (2002). Al-ishārāt wa al-tanbihāt. Qom: Bustane Ketab.-Isfahani, M. (2008).
-Nihāyat al-dirāyah fī sharḥ al-kifāyah. Beirut: Mu'assassat Alulbayt.-Kharrazi, S. (1997).  Bidāyat al-ma'ārif al-Ilāhiah fī sharḥ 'aqāeid al-imamiah. Qom: Al-nashar al-islami Institute.
-Khomeini, R. (1995). Anvār al-hidāyah fī al-ta'liqah ala al-kafāyah. Tehran:  The institute for compilation and publication of the works of Imam Khomeni.
-Lahiji, M. (1993). Sarmaye iman dar osūle e'teqadat. Tehran: Al-Zahra Publications.
-Mar'ashi, Q. (1989). Ihqāq al-haq wa izhāq al-bātil. Qom: Public Library of Ayatullah Najafī Mar'ashi.
-Misbah Yazdi, M. (2015). Falsafeye Akhlāq. Qom: Imam Khomeini Institute Publications.
-Momeni, A, Masjid Saraei, H. (2012). Asl andishi dar nizam hoquqie islam. Motaleate fīqh wa hoquqe islami.
-Moqniyeh, M. (1975). Ilm osūl al-fīqh fī thobeh al-jadid. Beirute: Dar al-Ilm lilmalaein.- Muzafar, M. (1996). Osūl al-fīqh. Qom: Ismaeilian.
-Naeini, M. (1997). Fawaed al-osūl. Qom: Daftar Intisharat Jame'e Modarresin.- Nasr al
-ding Tusi, M. (1985). Talkhis al-Mohassal. Beirut: Dar al-Azwa'.
-Qotb al-din Razi, M. (1983). Sharḥ al-ishārāt wa al-tanbihāt li-ltusi. Qom: Nashr al-Kitab Offīce.
-Sabzevari, M. (1993). Sharḥ al-asmā' al-Hosnā. Tehran: Tehran University Publication.
-Sadr, M. (1995). Jawāhir al-osūl. Beirut: Dar al-Taarof Lilmatbuat.
-Sadr, M. (1997). Bohūth fī 'ilm al-osūl. Beirut: al-dar al-islamiah.- Sanandaji, A. (). Taqrib al-marām fī sharḥ tahzib al-kalām. Cairo: Dar al-Basaer.
-Shirazi, N. (1991). Al-qawā'id al-fīqhiah. Qom: Imam Amir al-Momenin School.
-Sobhani, J. (2009). al-ilāhiāt alā hoda al-kitāb wa al-sunnah wa al-'aql. Qom: Imam al-Sadiq Institute.- Tabatabaei, S. (). Hāshiat al-Kifāyah. Qom: Bonyad Elmi wa Fīkri Alame Tabatabei.
- Tabatabaei, S. (1997). Al-mizān fī tafsir al-Quran. Qom: Daftar Intisharat Jame'e Modarresin.
 
Journal of Studies in Islamic Law & Jurisprudence
Volume 14, Issue 26
March 2022
Pages 31-58

Files

Share

How to cite

Statistics