The effects of separating legal matters from thematic matters in Islamic proceedings

Document Type : Original Article

Authors

1 Assistant Professor, Department of Law and Political Science, Yazd University

2 M.A of Private Law, Tehran University of Judicial Sciences and Administrative Services

3 PhD Student in Private Law, Ayatollah Haeri University

Abstract

In Islamic proceedings, more than any other measure, a distinction between judicial and thematic matters can help to facilitate a fair trial. Subjective matters are in the position of expressing an incident and incident, and in contrast, judicial matters consisting of law, legal rule, sources and valid Islamic fatwas and Judicial procedure in the general sense. According to the basic principle provided in the law, it is the duty of the litigants to present the matter and the judge has no right to intervene in this matter. Judicial matters are also within the exclusive duties of the judge and the maximum role of the litigants is to remind the judge and their actions are beyond their authority and power. Resolving the dispute by the judge and issuing a verdict by him, is basically subject to the separation of thematic matters from matters Judgment and order of matters is a matter of subject matter. Failure to separate judicial matters from thematic matters by judges, lawyers and experts on undesirable effects and problems such as delegating judgment to an expert, lack of proper oversight of the Supreme Court over the implementation of the law, issuing rulings outside the requested framework, and inappropriate interference of judges in matters. In this article, while comparatively analyzing thematic and legal matters in Imami jurisprudence and common law, the effects and benefits of separation between them will be stated, and criteria will be provided to distinguish legal matters from thematic ones in order to reduce the aforementioned possible effects using these findings

Keywords

References

-Abrishami, Entesar (2010), Duties and Powers of the Supreme Court in Comparison with Similar Institutions in the English Penal System, M.Sc. Thesis, Tehran: Faculty of Law, Shahid Beheshti University) in Persian)
-Almasi, Najad Ali (2015), Conflict of Laws, Ch 28, Tehran: University Publishing Center) in Persian)
-Ansari, Morteza (1419), Faraid al-Osul, vol. 2, ch. 1, Qom: Islamic Thought Association) In Arabic)
-Black، Henry(2004), Law Dictionary, 8Edition, New York:West Publishing Co. ) In English)
-Emami, Hassan (2012), Civil Law, Vol. 6, Ch. 14, Tehran: Islamic Publications) in Persian)
-Imanian Bidgoli, Azam (2012), Property Seekers in Civil Litigation, Ch 1, Tehran: Jangal Publications) in Persian)
-Bazgir, Yadollah (2001), Substantive Opinions of the Supreme Court in Legal and Criminal Matters, Ch 1, Tehran: Daneshnegar) in Persian)
-Tavassoli Jahromi, Manouchehr (2003), Proof and Proof, Law Quarterly Journal of Tehran School of Law and Political Science, Winter, Vol. 512) in Persian)
-Jafari Langroudi, Mohammad Jafar (2016), Legal Terminology, Ch 5, Tehran: Ganj-e-Danesh Publications) in Persian)
-Jafari Langroudi, Mohammad Jafar (2016), Legal Encyclopedia, Vol. 3, Ch. 2, Tehran: Ganj-e-Danesh Publications) in Persian)
-Hosseini Maraghi, Sayyid Abdo al-Fattah (1418), Alanavin, vol. 1, ch. 1, Qom: Islamic Publishing Institute) In Arabic)
-Hali, Abu Mansour Jamal al-Din Hassan Ibn Yusuf (Allama Hali) (1378 AH), Tahrir al-Ahkam, Ch 1, Qom: Imam Sadegh (AS) Institute. ) In Arabic)
-Khorasani, Mohammad Kazem (1413), Kefayeh al-Osul, Ch 1, Qom: Teachers Association Publications) In Arabic)
-Khaleghi, Ali (2015), Criminal Procedure, Vol. 1, Ch. 29, Tehran: Shahr-e-Danesh Publications) in Persian)
-Daryaei Reza, Karbalaei Aghazadeh, Mostafa (1397) Jurisprudential and Legal Analysis The position of description in a subject matter in civil proceedings, Doctrines of Civil Jurisprudence, 18,127-150) in Persian)
-Dehkhoda, Ali Akbar (1998), Dictionary, Volume 7, Number 1, Tehran: University of Tehran) in Persian)
-Shams, Abdullah (2014), "Causes, thematic matters and their description in civil litigation", Vol. 65, Journal of Legal Research, Spring, Vol. 65) in Persian)
- Shams, Abdullah (2016)Basic Civil Procedure, Vol. 1, Ch. 45, Tehran: Drak Publications) in Persian)
- Shams, Abdullah (2016) Basic Civil Procedure, Vol. 2, Ch. 35, Tehran: Drak Publications) in Persian)
- Shams, Abdullah (2011) Basic Civil Procedure, Vol. 3, Ch. 11, Tehran: Drak Publications) in Persian)
- Shams, Abdullah (2016) Evidence of Proof of Lawsuit, Ch 24, Tehran: Drak Publications) in Persian)
- Sahraei Movaneh, Nader (2014), Collection of Civil Procedure, Ch 4, Tehran: Chatar Danesh Publications) in Persian)
-Tahmasebi, Javad (1396), Criminal Procedure, Vol. 1, Ch. 3, Tehran: Mizan Publications) in Persian)
-Ameli, Muhammad ibn Maki (the first martyr) (Bita), Rules and benefits, vol. 1, ch. 1, Qom: Al-Mufid School) In Arabic)
-Aliabadi, Abdolhossein (1343), The theory of Dr. Abdolhossein Aliabadi, Attorney General in the substantive review of the branches of the Supreme Court, Journal of the Bar Association, December-December, Vol. 43) in Persian)
-Fazel Lankarani, Sheikh Mohammad (1420), Tafsil al-Sharia, Ch 1, Qom: Center for the Jurisprudence of the Imams) In Arabic)
-Fayyaz Bakhsh, Marjaneh and Asgarkhani; Abu Mohammad and Mir Abbasi, Seyed Baqer (1397), The Role of "Legal Principles" in removing the silence and silence of Iranian law (in the light of Article 3 of the Civil Procedure Code 1379), Journal of Islamic Jurisprudence and Law, Volume 10, Number 19 ) in Persian)
-Qazvini Hamedani, Ahmad Ibn Fars (1404), Dictionary of Language, Ch 1, Qom: Islamic Publishing Center) In Arabic)
-Ghaem Magham Farahani, Abdolmajid (2000), Evidence for Proving International and Domestic Lawsuits, Ch 1, Tehran: Avae Noor Publications) in Persian)
-Qafi, Hossein and Shariati Saeed (2013), Principles of Applied Jurisprudence, Volume 3, Number 7, Tehran: Samat Publications) in Persian)
-Ghamami, Majid, Ishraqi Arani, Mojtaba (2010) Practical and Theoretical Benefits of Separating Judgment from Subject Matter in Civil Proceedings, Journal of Private Law Studies, Vol. 40, pp. 267-286) in Persian)
-Katozian, Nasser (1997), The Validity of a Judgment in a Civil Litigation, Ch 5, Tehran: Dadgostar Publishing) in Persian)
- Katozian, Nasser(2011)  Philosophy of Law, Vol. 2, Ch. 4, Tehran: Anteshar Co. Publications) in Persian)
- Katozian, Nasser(2016)  Proof and Reason for Proof, Vol. 1, Ch. 9, Tehran: Mizan Legal Foundation) in Persian)
- Kirgis, F.Paul(2008)، The Right to a Jury Decision Questions of Fact Under the Seventh Amendment, Ohio State Journal, Vol.64, Oct) in English)
- Matin Daftari, Ahmad (2008), Civil and Commercial Procedure, Vol. 1, Ch. 1, Tehran: Majd Publications) in Persian)
- Mohseni, Hassan and Majid Ghamami (2007), Principles of Transnational Civil Procedure, Ch 1, Tehran: Mizan Publications) in Persian)
- Mohseni, Hassan (2010), Office ‌ Course ‌ Teaching ‌ Based on Cooperation ‌ Within the Framework ‌ Teaching Principles, Ch 1, Tehran: Company ‌ Joint Stock ‌ Publishing) in Persian)
- Mohammadi, Abolhassan (2012), Principles of Inference of Islamic Law, Ch 29, Tehran: Tehran University Press) in Persian)
- Madani, Jalaluddin (1998), Evidence of Proof of Lawsuit, Ch 4, Tehran: Paydar Publications) in Persian)
- Mazloumi, Sajjad (2008), The Supreme Court in the Iranian criminal justice system, Master Thesis, Tehran: Tehran School of Law and Political Science) in Persian)
- Mohajeri, Ali (2002), Description of the Code of Civil Procedure, Vol. 1, Ch. 2, Tehran: Ganj-e-Danesh Publications) in Persian)
 - Meshkini, Mirza Ali (1416), Terms of Principles and the Great of Research, Ch 6, Qom: Nashr al-Hadi) In Arabic)
- Muzaffar, Mohammad Reza (2016), Principles of Jurisprudence, Sharh Ali Mohammadi, Vol. 1, Ch. 14, Tehran: Dar al-Fikr Publications) In Arabic)
- Naeini, Mohammad Hussein (1997), Benefits of Principles, Vol. 1, Ch. 1, Qom: Islamic Publishing Institute) In Arabic)
- Naeini, Mohammad Hussein(2016) Benefits of Principles, vol. 3, ch. 1, Qom: Islamic Publishing Institute) In Arabic)
- Hormozi, Khairullah (2013), Changing the elements of litigation, Quarterly Journal of Private Law Research, Spring, Vol 3) in Persian)
- Levy, Prof(1957), Judicial Review Of Fact Questions, Harvard Law Review, Vol.70, Apr( in English)
- Zuckerman, A.S. Adrian(1986), Law, Fact Or Justice, Boston University Law Review, Vol.66, Aug( in English)
- Thayer B. James(1890), Law and Fact in Jury Trials , Harvard Law Review, Vol.4, Nov( in English)
 
Journal of Studies in Islamic Law & Jurisprudence
Volume 13, Issue 25
November 2021
Pages 153-176

Files

Share

How to cite

Statistics