Journal of Studies in Islamic Law & Jurisprudence

Journal of Studies in Islamic Law & Jurisprudence

Investigating the possibility of consensus from the perspective of Imami jurisprudence

Document Type : Original Article

Authors
Mohammad Mahdi Esmaelpour 1
Mohammad Hasan Haeri 2
Mohammad Taghi Ghabooli 3
1 Jurisprudence and Fundamentals of Law / Shahid Motahari Faculty of Theology / Ferdowsi University of Mashhad
2 Professor, Ferdowsi University of Mashhad / Faculty of Theology and Islamic Studies
3 Ferdowsi University
10.22075/feqh.2022.23628.2897
Abstract
At first glance, it may seem that many Imami jurists take the possibility of consensus for granted, while this will depend on our accepted definition of consensus and the basis of its authority. With definitions of consensus based on sense, conjecture, and grace, it is usually impossible for that to happen. From the author's point of view, it is impossible for all jurists in all ages with different tastes and intellectual backgrounds to issue fatwas in matters for which there is no valid evidence from verses and hadiths, and in case of such an agreement, a reassuring solution to know the fatwa. Not all jurists will exist. It seems that only if we accept the authority of consensus on the basis of reason, its occurrence will be in the position of proof and proof without hindrance, because in this case it is not necessary to study the opinion of all jurists, but the consent of most jurists or The famous people in the on the subject of consensus and the absence of the opposite promise ensures that the shari'ah agrees with on the subject of consensus. This research tries to examine the possibility of realizing consensus by re-reading the accepted definitions of consensus among Imami jurists and the principles of its authority.
Keywords
Consensus
The possibility of a consensus
The possibility to occurrence of a consensus
No disagreement
(Vefaq)
reputation (Shohrat)
(Madraki)
(Mohtamal -ul- Madrak)

  1. Quran

    Nahj –ul- Balagheh

    1. Ibn –e- Majeh, Mohammad Ibn –e- yazid (1974), Sonan –e- Ibn –e- MAJEH, Vol 3, Mesr: dar –ul- ehyae –el- kotob –el- Arabiyyah.
    2. Ibn –e- Hazm, Ali ibn –e- Ahmad (w.h), Al Ehkam fi osul –al- ahkam, Vol2, Gahere: Zakariyya Ali Yussof.
    3. Abu yaali, Mohammad ibn –e- Hasan (1989), Al oddah fi osul al feghh, Vol2, Riyaz: Jameaat ul malek Mohammad ibn Saood al eslamiyah.
    4. Al azdariy al Sajestani, Soleyman ibn –e- al Ashas (w.h), Sonan –e- Ibn Davud, Beyrut: Al maktabat ul asriyyah.
    5. Izedi, Ali Akbar (2010), “Common Law and its Role in the Derivation of Canonical Rules” , Journal of Studies in Islamic Law and Jurisprudence Issue.1, pp.45-73.
    6. Esbahani, Mahmud ibn –e- Abd ul Rahman (1985), Bayan ul mokhtasar fi sharh mokhtasar –e- ibn al Hajeb, VOL1, Riyaz: Dar ul Madani.
    7. Esfahani, Abul Hasan (w.h), Muntah al derayah ila ghavamez el kefayah, Vol5, Tehran: chapkaneh Ferdowsi.
    8. Esfahani, Mohammad Hosein (1993), Nahayat ul derayyah fi sharh al Kefayeh, VOL1, Qom: Al ul Beyt leehyae torath.
    9. Ansari, Morteza ibn Mohammad Amin (1998), Faraed ul osul, Vol2, Qom: Mjmae ol fekr al eslami.
    • Al irvani, Mohammad Bagher (1991), Al halghat ul thalethah fi oslubeh ah thani, Vol1,Qom: Al mohebbin letebaee va al nashr.
    • Agha bozorg Tehrani, Mohammad Hasan (1987), Al zarie letasanif al shie, Vol5, Qom: Esmaeeliyan.
    • Amodi, Ali ibn Abi Ali (w.h), Al Ehkam fi osul –el- Ahkam, Vol2, Beyrut: al maktab –ul- Eslami.
    • Termezi, Mohammad ibn –e- Isa (1976), Sonan, Vol12, Ghahere: matbaat ul Bali.
    • Jorjani, Ali ibn Mohammad (1983), Attaarifat, Vol3, Beyrut: dar ul kotob al elmiyah.
    • Aljarimato va al eghab fi el eslamm, Riyaz: vezart ol ughaf asoudiyah.
    • Hakeme Neyshaburi, Mohammad ibne Abdullah (1990), al mostadrak aala sahiheyn, Vol8, Beyrut: dar ul kotob al elmiyah.
    • Hakim, Seyed Mohsen (2012), Mostamsak ul Orveh, Vol6, Beyrut: dar ul Ehyae altorath ol arabi.
    • Hakim, seyed Mohammad Taghi (1979), al osul ul amah fi leltighh el mogharan, Vol2: Beyrut: al ul beyt.
    • Khoei, seyyed Abulgasem (1992), Mesbah ul osul, Vol2, Qom: Maktabat ul davari.
    • Saedi, Jaafar (2005), “Consensus in the shie thought”, Journal of jurisprudence of Ahlul Beyt, Issue. 42, pp.25-43.
    • Sobhani Tabrizi, Sheikh Jaafar (2009), Al vasit fi osul el figh, Vol4, Qom: emam Sadegh institution.
    • Sobhani Tabrizi, Sheikh Jaafar (1993), Al mahsol fi elm el osul, Vol3, Qom: emam Sadegh institution.
    • Sobhani Tabrizi, Sheikh Jaafar (2008), Al mojez fi osul el figh, Vol1, Qom: emam Sadegh institution.
    • Sobhani Tabrizi, Sheikh Jaafar (2004), Osul ul figh el mogharan fima la nassa fih, Vol2, Qom: emam Sadegh institution.
    • Sabzevari, Mulla Mohammad (w.h), Zakhirat ul maad fi sharh el ershad, Vol3, Qom: al ul beyt le ehyae torath.
    • Saadi, Abu jeyb (1995), Mosuat ul ejmaa, Vol2, Mesr: Dar ul hoda al nabavi.
    • Seyed e Morteza, Ali ibn Hoseyn (1967), Al zaria ela osul el sharie, Vol8, Tehran: daneshgah e Tehran.
    • Seyed e Morteza, Ali ibn Hoseyn (w.h), Rasael ul sharif, Vol1, Qom: Dar ul qoran el karim.
    • Shafei, Mohammad ebn Edris (1939), al resalat o leshafei, Vol2, Mesr: Maktabat ol halabi.
    • Shakeri, Belal (2016), “Restudy of Madrki consensus”, Journal of jurisprudence and fundamental, Issue.106, pp.45-66.
    • Sadr, Seyed Mohammad Bagher (1985), Druson fi elm el osul, Vol2, Beyrut: Darul kotob el Lobnani.
    • Tabarsi, Ahmad ibne Ali (2016), al Ehtejaj, Vol2, Beyrut: al Aalami lelmatbuat.
    • Abdul Wahabb, Khalaf (1942), Elm osul el figh va kholasat e tarikhe tashria, Vol6, Ghahere: Matbaat ol Madani.
    • Ariziye Khorasani, Hosein ibn Mohammad Ali (1990), arbao arajiz ol arbaeto al noriye, Vol2, Mashhad: Entesharat Astan Ghods.
    • Allame Helli, Hasan ibne Yusof (1985), Mabadiy ol vosul ela elm el osul, Vol2, Byrut: Dar ul azwhe.
    • Allame Helli, Hasan ibne Yusof (2004), Nahayat ol vosul ela elm el osul, Vol4, Qom: emam Sadegh.
    • Allame Helli, Hasan ibne Yusof (2001), Tahzib ol vosul ela elm el osul, Vol2, Qom: emam Ali.
    • Allame Majlesi, Mohammad Bagher (1983), Bahar ol anvar, Vol110, Beyrut: Darul Ehya el torath.
    • Qazali, Mohammad ebn Mohammad (1992), Al Mostasfa, Vol1, Beyrut: Darul kotob el elmiya.
    • Fazele Toni, Abdulah ibne Mohammad (1991), Al wafiyat o fi osul el figh, Vol1, Qom: Majma ol Fikr el eslami.
    • Fakhre Razi, Mohammad ibne Omar (1997), Al Mahsul, Vol3, Beyrut: al Resala.
    • Mobalghi, Ahmad (2004), Mosuat ol Ejmae fi fegh el Emamiye, Vol1, Qom: Bustane ketab.
    • Mohagheghe Heli, Jaafar ebn el Hasan (w.h), Maarej ol osul, Vol1, Qom: Al ul Beyt le ehyae el torath.
    • Mohammadi Khorasani, Ali (w.h), Sharhe osul e figh, Vol5, Qom: Dar ol fekr.
    • Moravej Jazayeri, Seyed Mohammad Jaafar (1992), Montaha al derayah, Vol4, Qom: Dar ol kotob el Jazayeri.
    • Mostafavi, Seyed Mohammad (2020/5/9), Darse khareje osul, eshia.ir/feqh/archive/text/mostafavi/osool/94/941027/
    • Mozafar, Mohammad Reza (2009), Osul ol fiqh, Vol2, Qom: Al nashr ol eslami.
    • Makarem Shirazi, Naser (2007), Anvar ol osul, Vol2, Qom: Madresat ol Emam Ali yobne Abi taleb.
    • Montahaee, Abas (2001), “Elme osule fiqh va sar chashme haye bashari”, Journal of Kanun, Issue.26, pp108-117.
    • Musavi Khomeini, Seyed Ruhollah (2006), Anvar ol hedaye fi taalighat ala al kefaye, Vol2, Tehran: Moaseseye Tanzime va nashre asare emam Khomeini.
    • Mirzaye Qomi, Abol Qasem (1956), Ghavanin ol osul, Vol2, Qom: Maktabat ol islami.
    • Naeeni, Mirza Mohammad Hosein (1997), Favaed ol osul, Vol1, Qom: Jamee Modaresin.
    • Najafi, Mohammad Hasan (1983), Jawaher ol Kalam, Vol7, Beyrut: Dar ul ehyae torath el arabi.
    • Vahid e Behbahani, Mohammad Baqer (1995), Resael ol osuliye, Vol1, Qom: Moasesat ol Allamat ol mojaded ol Vahid ol Behbahani.
    • Vahid e Behbahani, Mohammad Baqer (1994), Al favaed ul Haeri, Vol1, Qom: Majm ol fikr el eslami.
    • Hashemi Shahudi, Seyed Mahmood (1996), Bohuthon fi elm el osul, Vol2, Qom: Al Qadir le derasat el eslamiye.
Journal of Studies in Islamic Law & Jurisprudence
Volume 15, Issue 30
Spring 2023
Pages 177-204