Temporary Imprisonment Sentence for the Debtor Claiming Insolvency from the Perspective of Iranian Jurisprudence and Law

Document Type : Original Article

Authors

1 Associate Professor of Fiqh and Fundamentals of Islamic Law, University of Tehran

2 Department of Jurisprudence and Fundamentals of Islamic Law, Faculty of Theology, University of Tehran

3 Ferdowsi Mashhad University

Abstract

The possibility of using criminal tools in legal affairs is a matter of dispute between jurists. If a person is accused of committing a crime, the possibility of his arrest has been accepted in some cases, but the use of such punitive measures in legal matters requires the examination of its authorization or prohibition from a jurisprudential and legal perspective. The conflict of rights between creditors and debtors has led to disagreements in this regard. Considering that the principle in initial treatment of individuals is that their actions are based on integrity and innocence, it seems that if the debtor claims insolvency, it will not be possible to detain him until the truth or falsity of his claim is proven. Imami and Sunni jurists have also examined this matter- an examination of the evidence of their rulings will also demonstrate that it is not possible to order the arrest of a debtor claiming insolvency. In this article, the correct ruling in this case will be determined through the epistemology of this important point of view from perspectives of the jurists of both sects and judging the proposed opinions. Noting the correct theory in jurisprudence, we will provide a detail interpretation of the relevant laws applicable to the debtor claiming insolvency.

Keywords

References

 
-Ebn Teymeyeh (1896)، al-Ekhtebarat al-Elmeyeh (Al-Fatava al-Kobra)،j2، Beyroot: Dar al-Maarefeh.
- Ebn Jallab (1987)، al-Tafreea، j2، Beyroot: Dar al-gharb al-Eslamee.
- Ardebeeli، ahmad Ebn Mohammad (1983)، Majmaa al-Faede Va Al-Borhan Fi Sharh Ershad al-Azhan،
j12، Qom: dafar entesharat vabasteh be jameae madarresin hozeh elmeyeeh qom.
- Asbahi، Malek Ebn Anas (1991)، al-Modavvanah al-Kobra، Beyroot: Dar al-Sader.
- al-Mortaza، Ahmad Ebn Yahya (1996)،Oyoon al-Azhar، Beyroot: Dar al-Kotof al-Lobnone.
- Andelosi،EBN al-Hazm (1991)، al-Mohalla، j8، Beyroot: Dar Al-Afaq al-Jadeedah.
- Basti (1992)، Maalem al-Sonan، J4، al-Maktabah Al-Elmeeyah.
-Hor Ameli، Mohammad Ebn Hasan Sheykh Hor Amelee (1989)، Vasayel al-Sheae، j41،40،18،13، Qom:  Moasseseh All al-Beyt.
- Halabi، Aboo Al-Salah (1983)، al-Kafi Fi al-Fegh، Esfahan: Ketabkhaneh Emam Ali.
- Helli (Allameh)، Hasan Ebn Yousef Ebn Motahhar (1994)، Tazkereh al-Foghahaa، j17، Qom: Moasseseh All al-Beyt.
- Helli (Allameh)، Hasan Ebn Yousef Ebn Motahhar (1993)، GHavaed al-Ahkam، Qom: Daftar Entesharat Eslami.
- Helli (Fakhr al-MIHAGHGHEGHIN)، Mohammad Ebn Hasan Ebn Yousef (1967)، Izah al-Favaed Fi Sharh Moshkelat al-Qavaed، j3، Qom: Miasseseh Esmailian.
-Helli (Mohaghegh Helli) Aboo Jaafar (1997)، al-Mokhtasar al-Nafea، j1، chap sheshom، Qom: al-Matbooat al-diniyah.
-  Helli (Mohaghegh Helli) Aboo Jaafar (1987)، al-Sh’aria al-Islam، j4، chap  dovvom، Qom: Mosseseh Esmaillian.
- Helli، Yahya Ebn Saead (1984)، al-Jamea le Sh’aria، Qom: Moasseseh Seyed al-Shohada.
- Khansari، Ahmad (1984)، Jamea al-Madarek، j6، chap dovvom، Qom: Mosseseh Esmaillian.
- Sallar Deylami، Hamzeh Ebn Abd al-Aziz (1983)، al-Marasem al-Alaviyeh va al-Ahkam al-Nabaviyeh، Qom: Manshoorat al-Harameyn.
- Siyoori (Fazel Meghdad)، Meghdad Ebn Abd Allah (2004)، Kanz al-Erfan Fi Fegh al-Qoran، Bakhshayeshi، j2، chap avval، Pasaj Qods.
- Shahabi، Mahmood Ebn Abd al-Salam Torbati (1996)، Advar Fegh، 3 jeld، chap panjom، Tehran: Sazman Chap Va Entesharat.
- Shookani، Mohammad Ebn Ali (1992)، Neyl al-Otar، j7 ، Beyroot: Dar al-Kotob al-Elmiyeh.
- Sanani، Abd al-Razzagh Ebn Homam (1984)، al-Mosannaf، j10، al-Manshoorat، be tahghigh habib vahman al-Azami.
- Tabatabai، Ali Ebn Mohammad (1997)، Reyaz al-Masael، j15، Qom: Moasseseh All al-Beyt.
- Tabasi، Najm al-Din (1948)، Hoghoogh Zendani، Qo: Boostan Ketab.
- Toosi، Mihammad Ebn Hasan Aboo Jafar (1970)، al-Estebsar، j3، Tehran: Dar al-Kotob al-Eslamiyeh.
- Toosi، Mihammad Ebn Hasan Aboo Jafar (1987)، Tahzib al-Ahkam، j6، chap chaharom، Tehran: Dar al-Kotob al-Eslamiyeh.
- Toosi، Mihammad Ebn Hasan Aboo Jafar (1987)، al-Khelaf، shesh jeld، Qom: dafar entesharat vabasteh be jameae madarresin hozeh elmeyeeh qom.
- Toosi، Mihammad Ebn Hasan Aboo Jafar (1980)، al-Nehayeh Fi Mojarad al-Fegh Va al-Fatava، chap dovvom، Beuroot: Dar al-Kotob al-Arabi.
- Toosi، Mihammad Ebn Hasan Aboo Jafar (2009)، al-Mabsoot Fi Fegh al-Emamiyeh، j2، chap sevvom، Tehran: Maktabah al-Mortazaviyah.
- Ameli، Seysd Mohammad Javad Hoseyni (1992)، Meftah al-KerameH، j10، Beyroot: Dar Ehya al-
Toras al-Arabi.
-Abd al-Ghader Oodah (bi ta)، al-Tashria al_Jenaee al-Eslami Mogharenan Belghanoon al-Vazee، Beyroot: Dar al-Kotob al-Arabi.
- Feyz Kashani، Mohammad Mohsen Ebn Mortaza (1992)، Mafatih al_Sharia، j2، Qom: Ayat Allah Marashi Najafi.
- Ghazafi، Shahab al-Din Ahmad Ebn Edris (1992( ، al-Foroogh، j4 Beyroot: Dar al-Maarefeh.
- Ghazvini Termezi، Ebn Maje al-Sonan (1985)، Sonan al-Termezi، j4، chap dovvom، Beyroot: Dar al-Fekr.
- Katani، Abd al-Hayy (1989)،al-Taratib al_ Edareyah، j1، Beyroot: Dar al-Kotob al-Arabi.
- Karaki (Mohaghegh Sani)، Abd al-Aala Ali Ebn Hoseyn (1996)، Jamea al-Maghased Fi Sharh al-Ghavaed، j6، chap dovvom، Qom: Moasseseh All al-Beyt.
- Kooshki، Gholamhasan (2021)، Ahdaf Nezam Dadresi Keyfari، Cheshm Andaz Eslami، Motaleat Fegh Va Hoghoogh Eslami، 25، 339-358.
- Kolryni، Mohammad Ebn Yaghoob (1989)، al-Kafi، j 2 Va 4، chap chaharom، Tehran: Dar al-Kotob al-Eslamiyeh.
- Kani، Sheykh Mirza Ali (bi ta)، al-Ghaza Men Ketab Tahghigh al-Dalael Fi Sharh Talkhis al-Masael، chap Sangi.
- Koofi، Ebn Abi Shabih (1989)، al-Mosanaf، j8، Beyroot: Dar al-Fekr.
- Maverdi، Abolhasan (1994)، al-Ahkam al-Sltaniyah، Qom: Daftar Entesharat Eslami.
- Majlesi avval، Mohammad Taghi (1988)، Rozah al-Motaghin، j6، chap davvom، Qom: Mosseseh Farhangi Eslami Kooshanpoor.
- Majlesi dovvom (Allameh Majlesi)، Mohammad Bagher Ebn Mohamman Taghi (1988)، Malaz al-Akhyar، j10، Qom: Ketabkhaneh Marashi Najafi.
- Mohammad Ebn Maki (Shahid Avval) (1979)، al-Ghavaed Va al-Favaed، j2، Ketab Forooshi Mofid.
- Mihammadi Khirasani، Ali (1997)، Sharh Tabserah al-Mojealemin، Tehran.
- Mofid، Mohammad Ebn Noaman (1992)، al-Maghnaah،chap avval، Qom: Kongereh Jahani Hazareh Sheykh Mofid.
- Maghrebi، Aboo Hanifeh (1965)، daaem al-Eslam، j2، chap davvom، Qom: Moasseseh All al-Beyt.
- Moghaddasi، Aboo Mohammad Abd Allah Ebn Ahmad Ebn Mihammad Ebn Ghodameh (1965)، al-Mghani، j4، Beyroot Agam al-Kotob.
- Moosavi Khomeyni (Emam Khomeyni)، Rooh Allah (2004)، Tahrir al-Vasileh، motarjem: Eslami، Ali، j4،2، Qom: Entesharat Eslami.
- Moosavi Ghazvini، Seyed Ali (2003)، Yanabia al-Ahkam، Fi Maarefat al-Halal Va al-Haram، j2، Qom: Entesharat Eslami.
- Najafi، Mohammad hasan (1993)، Javaher al-Kalam، [28Va38، chap haftom، Beyroot: Dar Ehyaa al-Toras.
- Naraghi، Moga Ahmad (1994)، Misjanad al-sheeah Fi Ahkam al-Shariah، j15، Qom: Moasseseh All al-Beyt.
 
Journal of Studies in Islamic Law & Jurisprudence
Volume 14, Issue 28
October 2022
Pages 131-156

Files

Share

How to cite

Statistics