Criticizing the theory of illegitimacy of martyrdom operation, referring to Jurisprudential sources

Hashemi Khan Abbasi, Seyyed Ali; Kaliji, Somayyh

doi:10.22075/feqh.2021.23450.2871

Criticizing the theory of illegitimacy of martyrdom operation, referring to Jurisprudential sources

Document Type : Original Article

Authors

Seyyed Ali Hashemi Khan Abbasi ¹

Somayyh Kaliji ²

¹ Assistant Professor of jurisprudence and Islamic law of Sari University of Agricultural Sciences and Natural Resources

² Al-Zahra Educational Institute in Babol, Iran

10.22075/feqh.2021.23450.2871

Abstract

Imamiah jurisprudence, to prevent any hegemony and invasion of the enemies of the religion, introduced Jihad, defensive operations by invasion factors in fact.
Defending against aggressors, while lacking proper military possibilities, leads to specific ways of defeating, martyrdom operation could be a clear example.
Martyrdom Operation, is a modern way of resisting and encountering enemies of Islam using newly made fatal tools and equipment, with the aim of approaching God. The agent is sure that he shall be martyred or he shall be most suspected of being martyred. While martyrdom operation resembles suicidal operation, some of experts consider it illegal.
The present study, using analytical and library way of research, reviewing Jurisprudential sources and various researches and studying Jurisprudential reasons and basics by dissidents of martyrdom operation as well, concluded that martyrdom operation, while being different from suicidal operation, is religiously legal. The reasons announced by the dissidents are not considered valid due to the aim and intension of operation.

Keywords

Martyrdom

Suicide

martyrdom operation

Jurisprudential sources

Illegitimacy

The Holy Quran, translated by Naser Makarem Shirazi
Nahjolbalagheh, translated by Mohammad Dashti
Ebne Seyedeh,Ali Ebne Smaeil (no date of publication), Al-mohkam o Al-mohit Al-azam, researched by Abdolhamid Handavi, 4^th volume, 1^st publication, Beirut, Dar-ol Kotob Elmie.
Ebne Manzour, MohammadEbne Mokaram, (1993-94), Lesan Al-arab, 3^rd and 6^th volumes, 3^rd publication, Beirut, Dar Sader.
Elhami and Pourlotfollah, Reza and Hassan, (1976-77), Jarayane Ghaedeh Aham va Mohem Dar Ekrah be Ghatl, published by Motaleat Fighh va Hoghoughe Eslami, pgs. 11, 9-36
Al-ansari, Zakaria Ebne Mohammad Ebne Zakaria, Valestiki, Zeinoldin Abou Yahya, (no date of publication), Asnial Mataleb fi sharhe Rouzoltaleb, 4^th volume, no center of publication, Darolketabe Eslami.
Ansari Dezfouli, Morteza, (no date of publication), Ghaedeh La Zarar va Alyad-o Alseha-o Alghora, (Gharedol Osoul), 1^st print, Qom, Islamic Publication Center.
Ansari Dezfouli, Morteza, (1993-94), Rasael Feghhie, 1^st print, Qom, Alfekrol Esmai Center
Bagheri, Hassan, Salemi, Morteza, (2002-03), Amaliate Esteshhadi, Chera ava Chegouneh, Tehran, Nazir publication
Termezi, Mohammad Ebne Eisa, (1998), Sonan al Termezi, 2^nd and 4^th volume, researched by Bashar Avad Marouf, Beirut, Dar-ol Gharb-el Eslami
Jafari, Mohammadtaghi, (no date of publication), Jurisprudence Resources, no center of publication, no publication
Some authors, (2010-11), Mousoue Alfeghhe Aleslami, 17^th volume, Qom, Daerat-ol Maaref-ol Feghhe-l Eslami Institute
Johari, Esmaeil Ebne Hamad, (no date of publication), Alsahah, 2^nd 3^rd volume, researched and reviewed by Ahmad Abdolghafour Atar, 1^st print, Beiru, Darol Elm Lel Molaein
Haeri Tehrani, Mirseyed Ali, (1998-99), Moghtaniat-ol Dar and Moltaghiat-ol Samar, 3^rd volume, Tehran, Darol Kotob Eslami
Hurr Ameli, Mohammad Ebne Hassan, (1988-89), Vasael-ol Shia, 15^th and 29^th volume, 1^st print, Qom, Ale Albeit Alaihe Alsalam institute
Montazeri, Hossein Ali, (1992-93), Alahkam Alsharia Ala Mazha ahle AlbBeit Alaihe Alsalam, 1^st print, Qom, Tafakor Publication
Hosseini Rouhani Qomi, Seyedsadegh, (1991-92), Feghhe Alsadegh Alaihe Alsalam, 3^rd volume, 1^st print, Qom, Darolketab, Emam Sadegh peace be upon him School
Helli (Allameh), Hassan Ebne Yousof Ebne Motahar, (1993-94), Tazkaratol Foghaha, 9^th volume, 1^st print, Qom, Ale Albeit Alaihe Alsalam institute
Helli (Fakhrolmohagheghin), Mohammad Ebne Hassan, (1967-68), Eizah-ol Favaed fi Sharhe Moshkelat-ol Ghavaed, 1^st volume, 1^st print, Qom, Esmaeilian Institute
Helli (Mohaghegh), Jafar Ebne Hassan, (1987-88), Sharae Aleslam fi Masael-el Halal va Alharam, 1^st and 4^th volume, 2^nd print, Qom, Esmaeilian Institute
Helli, Ahmad Ebne Mohammad, (1987-88), Almohzab-ol Bare fi Sharh-el Mokhtasar-el Nafe, 1^st volume, 1^st print, Qom, Islamic Publication Office, subordinated to teachers’ society
Heidari, Mohammad, (2002-03), Mo’jam-ol Af’al-ol Motadavel, Almarkaz-ol Alami Leldarasat-ol Eslamie, Qom, 1^st print
Alkhami-ol Shami Abolghasem Altirani, Soleiman Ebne Ahmad, (no date of publication), Almo’jam-ol Kabir, 7^th and 13^th volume, researched by Hamdi Ebne Abd-ol Majid-ol Sofla, published by Maktabate Ebne Timieh, Cairo, 2^nd print
Khansari, Seyedahmed Ebne Yousof, (1985-86), Jame-ol Madarek fi Sharhe Mokhtasar-el nafe, 5^th volume, Esmaeilian Institute, Qom, 2^nd print
Zobeidi, Morteza, (no date of publication), Taj-ol Arous, 7^th and 8^th volume, researched by Ali Shiri, Dar-ol Fekr, Beirut, 1^st print
Zoheili, Vahbat Ebne Mostafa, (2001-02), Tafsir-ol Vasit, 6^th volume, Dar-ol Fekr, Damascus, 1^st print
Sejestani, Aboudavoud Soleiman Ebn-el Ash’as, (2009-10), Sonane Abi Davoud, 4^th and 7^th volume, 1^st print, research: Shoeib-al Arnout and Mohammad Kamel Gharah Belli, (no center of publication), Dar-ol Resale Alalamie
Sa’di, Aboujeib, (no date of publication), Alghamous-ol Feghhi Loghat va Estelah, 2^nd print, Damascus, Dar-ol Fekr
Shafiei Nia, Ahmad, (2011-12), Feghh-ol Moghavemat: Derasat Moghareneh, 1^st print, Tehran, Almajma-ol Alami Leltaghrib Bein-ol Almazaheb-el Eslamieh
Shoukani, Mohammad Ebne Ali, (no date of publication), Nil-ol Autar Men Ahadis Seyed-ol Akhyar Sharhe Montaghi-ol Akhbar, 11^th volume, (no center of publication), (no publisher)
Alsheibani, Ahmad Ebne Mohammad, (no date of publication), Masnad-ol Emam Ahmad Ebne Hanbal, researched by Ahmad Mohammad Shaker, 2^nd and 5^th volume, 1^st print, Cairo, Dar-ol Hadis
Sheibani, Mohammad Ebne Hassan, (no date of publication), Alseir-ol Kabir, 1^st volume, (no center of publication), (no publisher)
Tabatabaei Taheri, Seyedali, (1997-98), Riaz-ol Masael, 8^th volume, 1^st print, Qom, Ale AlbBeit Alaihe Alsalam
Tabatabaei Hakim, Seyed Mohsen, (1995-96), Mostamsak-ol Orvat-ol Vosgha, 3^rd volume, 1^st print, Qom, Dar-ol Tafsir Institute
Tabatabaei, Seyedmohammad Hossein, (1996-97), Almizan Fi Tafsir-al Quran, 2^nd, 4^th and 14^th volume, 5^th print, Qom, teachers’ society Publication Office, Qom
Terablesi, Ebne Baraj, (1986-87), Almahzab, 1^st volume, 1^st print, Qom, Islamic Publication Office, subordinated to teachers’ society
Toosi, Mohammad Ebne Hassan, (1980-81), Alnahayat fi Mojarad-ol Feghhe va Alfatavi, 2^nd print, Beirut, Dar-ol Ketab Arabi
Ameli, (Shahid Sani), Zeinoddin Ebne Ali, (1989-90), Alrozat-ol Bahie fi Sharh-al Lam’at-ol Dameshghie, 2^nd volume, 1^st print, Qom, Davari Book Store
Ameli, (Shahid Sani), Zeinoddin Ebne Ali, (1992-93), Masalek-ol Afham ela Tanghihe Sharae-ol Eslam, 3^rd and 15^th volume, 1^st print, Qom, Almaaref-ol Eslamieh Institute
Alasghalani, Ahmad Ebne Ali Ebne Hajr, (no date of publication), Fath-ol Bari be Sharhe Sahih-ol Bokhari, researched and reviewed by Abdolaziz Ebne Abdollah Ebne Yaz, 6^th volume, Beirut, Dar-ol Marefah
Fazel Abi, Hassan Ebne Abitaleb Yousof, (1996-97), Kashfol Romouz fi Sharhe Mokhtasar-ol Manafe, 1^st volume, 3^rd print, Qom, Islamic Publication Office
Farahidi, Khalil Ebne Ahmad, (no date of publication), Al-ein, 3^rd volume, 2^nd print, Qom, Hejrat Publication
Fazlollah, Seyedmohammadhossein, (1998-99), Tafsir Men Vahy-el Quran, 7^th volume, 2^nd print, Beirut, Dar-ol Melek Letabat va Alnashr
Firahi, Davoud, (2004-05), Legitimate Defense, Assassination and martyrdom operation in Shia, Specialized Quarterly in Shia Studies, 6, 119-120
Firouzabadi, Mohammad Ebne Yaqub, (no date of publication), Alghamous-ol Mohit, 1^st snd 2^nd volume, 1^st print, Beirut, Dar-ol Kotob-ol Elmie
Ghayoumi, Ahmad Ebne Mohammad, (no date of publication), Almesbah-ol Monir, 2^nd volume, 2^nd print, Qom, Dar-ol Hejrat Institute
Ghertabi, Mohammad Ebne Ahmad, (1985-86), Tafsire Ghertabi (Aljame-ol Ahkam-ol Quran), 1stand 5^th volume, Tehran, Naser Khosro Publication
Ghommi, (Sadough), Mohammad Ebne Ali, (1992-93), Man La Yahzar-hol Faghih, 3^rd and 4^th volume 2^nd print, Qom, Islamic Publication Office, subordinated to teachers’ society
Kashani, (Feiz), Mohammad Mohsen, (1986-87), Alvafi, 3^rd vlolume, 1^st print, Esfahan, Emam Amir-al Momenin Ali (peace be upon him) Library
Alkahlani Som-ol Sanani, Mohammad Ebne Esmaeil Ebne Salah Ebne Mohammad Alhasani, (no date of publication), S0bol-ol Salam, 2^nd volume, no center of publication, Dar-ol Hadis
Kalini, Mohammad Ebne Yaqub, (1987-88), Alkafi, 3^rd , 5^th and 10^th volume, 4^th print, Tehran, Dar-ol Kotob-al Eslamieh
Maleki Najafi, (Kashef-ol Ghata), Jafar ebne Khezr, (no date of publication), Kashf-ol Gheta an Mobhamat-ol Shariat-ol Ghara, 4^th volume, 1^st print, Qom, Islamic Advertisement Office Publication
Mohaghegh Damad, Seyedmostafa, (1986-87), Ghavaed Feghh, 1^st volume, 12^th print, Tehran, Islamic Sciences Publication Center
Makarem Shirazi, Naser, (1995-96), Tafsire Nemouneh, 2^nd and 3^rd volume, 1^st print, Tehran, Dar-ol Kotob-al Eslamieh
Makarem Shirazi, Naser, (2012-13), 600 Masale Kasir-ol Ebtela, Qom, Emam Ali Ebne Abitaleb School
Molahvish Al Ghazi, Abdolghader, (1962-63), Bayan-ol Maani, 5^th volume, 1^st print, Damascus, Matbaat-ol Taraghi
Mola Mohhamadali, Amir, (2006-07), Mabani Feghhi Amaliate Esteshhadi, 1^st print, Qom, Zamzam Hedayat
Montazeri Najafabadi, Hosseinali, (1992-93), Alahkam-ol Sharia ala Mazhabe Ahl-el Beit Alaihem Alsalam, 1^st print, Qom, Tafakor publication
Mousavi Khomeini, Seyedrouhollah, (no date of publication), Tahrir-ol Vasile, 1^st and 2^nd volume, 1^st print, Qom, Dar-ol Elm Institute
Mousavi Khomeini, Seyedrouhollah, (1982-83), Sahife Noor, 14^th and 19^th volume, Tehran, Islamic Culture and Revolution Center
Mousavi Sabzavari, Seyedabdolala, (1988-89), Mavaheb-ol Rahman fi Tafsir-el Quran, 3^rd and 8^th volume, 2^nd print, Beirut, (no publisher)
Mousavi Sabzavari, Seyedabdolala, (1992-93), Mahzab-ol Ahkam, 15^th volume, 4^th print, Qom, Almenar Institute, Ayatollah Abdolala Office
Najafi (of Saheb Aljavaher), Mohammadhassan, (1984-85), Javaher-ol Ahkam fi Sharhe Sharae-ol Eslam, 21^st volume, 7^th print, Beirut, Dar Ehya-al Taras-al Arabi
Nouvi Javi, Mohammad Ebne Omar, (1996-97), Marah Lebid Lekashfe Mani-el Quran-el Majid, 1^st and 2^nd volume, 1^st print, Beirut, Dar-ol Kotob-al Eslamieh
Varaei, Seyedjavad, (2003-04), Mabani Feghhi Amaliate Shadat Talabane, Islamic Government Publication, 27, 319

Journal of Studies in Islamic Law & Jurisprudence

Volume 14, Issue 26
Winter 2022
Pages 387-418

XML

PDF 709.15 K

Article View 580
PDF Download 1,372

Journal of Studies in Islamic Law & Jurisprudence

Criticizing the theory of illegitimacy of martyrdom operation, referring to Jurisprudential sources

Volume 14, Issue 26Winter 2022Pages 387-418

Files

Share

How to cite

Statistics

Volume 14, Issue 26
Winter 2022
Pages 387-418