Feasibility of Refer to Popular Vote to Enact Laws About Crime and Punishment in Islam, Iran and Italy’s Legal Systems

Document Type : Original Article

Authors

1 Dameghan University

2 Ferdowsi University -Mashahd,-Iran

Abstract

Article 59 of the Iranian Constitution mentions the possibility of refer to popular vote through referendum on very important issues. One of the examples of this direct legislation is to enact laws about crimes and punishments; until today, the Iranian legal system has not referred to the referendum in general and to the legislative referendum in criminal matters in particular. It may be argued that given the impact of Islam on some crimes and punishments in Iran, Basically, referring to the opinions of the people on the mentioned issues should have a religious restriction. However, governments like Italy have used legislative referendums about criminal issues; according to Article 75 of the Italian Constitution, a referendum can repeal a parliamentary law, and this rule has been implemented at various times, even in criminal policy. In this study, using a descriptive-analytical method and after examining the principles of referring to public opinion in criminal matters from an Islamic perspective and presenting the features related to the Iranian and Italian systems, we will reach the conclusion that holding a referendum to determine criminal policy in Iran, provided that certain conditions are respected, not only has no legal and religious prohibition, but getting ideas from the Italian procedure can be considered a significant help in achieving the following issues: Improving the quality of governance of the Islamic Republic, increasing the level of mutual trust between people and the rulers and finally adapting the situation of crimes and punishments to the current concerns of society. This does not mean that the state should not monitor the implementation of referendums to avoid non-rational decisions by the people.

Keywords

References

  1. Abrishami Rad, Moḥammad Amin, Jalali, Alireza. (2020). “Rules of Holding a Legislative referendum and necessary supervisions in Iran and Italy”, Constitutional Law Review, vol 17(33), 188-208. (in Persian)
  2. Abrishami Rad, Moḥammad Amin, Nikounahad, Hamed. (2020). “Intentionalist Interpretation of the Supreme Leader’s Authority in Issuing Referendum: The Subject of Article 110(3) of Iran’s Constitution”, Public Law Research, 21(66), 382-406. (in Persian)
  3. Ibn Khaldun, Abdul Rahman (1980), Muqaddimah, translated by Muḥammad Parvin Gonabadi, vol 4, Tehran: bongahe tarjome va nashre ketab. (in Persian)
  4. Breathnach, Seamus (2008), Emile Durkheim On Crime and Punishment, translated by Muḥammad Ja’afar Saed, 1st, Tehran: Khorsandi. (in Persian)
  5. Taskhiri, Muḥammad Ali (2006), In the light of Islamic Republic of Iran Constitution, translated by Muḥammad Sepehri, 1st, Tehran: The World Forum for Proximity of Islamic Schools of Thought - Culture Secretary. (in Persian)
  6. Jalali, Alireza, Gorji, Ali Akbar. (2019). “Participatory Democracy and Municipal Referendums in Italian Legal System: A Model to Complete the Iranian Legal System”, Comparative Law Review, 10(2), 429-448. (in Persian)
  7. Janati, Ebrahim (2009), "Development of Interpretation if Islamic Jurisprudence in the Passing of Time”, Fiqh, 59 and 60, Spring, pp. 62-25. (in Persian)
  8. Hur Ameli, Muḥammad ibn Hassan (No date), Wasa'il al-Shia, Beirut: al-Ehya Alterath Al-Arabia Publication. (in Arabic)
  9. Khansari, Sayyid Ahmad (2013), Jame ol' Madarek, Vol. 5, 1st, Tehran: Al-Sadough School. (in Arabic)
  10. Khan Muḥammadi, Yousuf (2013), “Political Interpretation of the Quran in Contemporary Iran”, Qom: Islamic Sciences and Culture Academy. (in Persian)
  11. Darvishvand, Abolfazl (2014), Detailed Explanation of the Constitution Description of the One Hundred and Twenty-Third Principle of the Constitution, under the supervision of Abbas Ali Kadkhodai, Guardian Council Research Institute. (in Persian)
  12. Rashid Reza, Muḥammad (2007), Yasir al-Salam va osole al-tashrie al-ām (fi nahye allah va rasool an kesrah saval), Cairo: Dar al-Manar. (in Arabic)
  13. Saed Vakil, Amir and Askari, Pouria (2015), Constitution in the Nowadays Legal Order, 7th, Tehran: Majd Publication. (in Persian)
  14. Sha’abani, Ghasem (2015), Constitutional Rights and the Structure of the Government of the Islamic Republic of Iran, Tehran: Ettela'at Publication. (in Persian)
  15. Shams al-Dīn, Muḥammad Mahdī (1999), Fe al-ejmahe al-siyasi al-eslami: al-mojtama al-siyasi al-eslami: mohavelat al-taseel feghhi va tarikhi, Beirut: moaseseh al-arabiyah.al-duwlayh leldirasat wa al-nashr. (in Arabic)
  16. Sadr, Sayyid Muḥammad Baqir (2000), Al-eslam yaghod al-hayat mosoa al-shahid al-sadr, 1st، qom: markaz al-ebhas va al-derasat al-takhsisiyah lel-shahid al-sadr. (in Arabic)
  17. Sadr, Sayyid Muḥammad Baqir (No date), Jawahir al-Osoul, Beirut: Dar al-Ta'rif lil Matboua’at. (in Arabic)
  18. Tahanantif, Hadi and Mumtaznia, Muḥammad Saeed (2019), "Legislative Referendum in the Legal System of the Islamic Republic of Iran", Journal of Islamic Law, Year 20, Vol 2 (50 consecutive), Autumn and Winter, pp. 448-421. (in Persian)
  19. Allameh Helli (No date), Kashf al-morad fi sharhe tajrid al-eteghad ghesm al-elahiyat, (No place), (No name). (in Arabic)
  20. Ali, Jawad (1971), al-Mofassal fī tārīkh al-'Arab qabla al-Islām, vol. 5, Baghdad: Maktabah al-Nahda va Dar al-elm lel-molayeen. (in Arabic)
  21. Amid Zanjani, Abbas Ali (2000), Political Jurisprudence, vols. 1 and 2, 4th, Tehran: Amir Kabir Publication. (in Persian)
  22. Oudah, Abdul Qader (No date), al-Tashrīʻ al-jināʼi al-islāmī muqāranan bi-al-qānūn al-waḍʻī', Beirut: Dar Al-Kateeb Al-Arabi (in Arabic)
  23. Oudah, Abdul Qader (1981), Islam and our political situation, Beirut: The Foundation for Printing, Publishing and Distribution.
  24. Gharavi Naeini, Muḥammad Hassan (2014), Tanbih al-Ummah wa Tanzih Al-Milla, research by Sayyid Jawad Varei, Qom: Boustane Ketab. (in Arabic)
  25. Al-Ghazali, Muḥammad ibn Muḥammad (1997), Almstasfy men Elm AL Osoul, Beirut: Al-Risalah Foundation. (in Arabic)
  26. Fassi, Allal (1991), Maqasid al-Shariah al- Islamiyah and Makremeha, 4th, Robat: Dar al-Aman Publication. (in Arabic)
  27. Fadhil, Muqdad bin Abdullah (1984), Al-Tanqih al-Ra elMukhtasar al-Shara'i', Qom: Library of Ayatollah Al-Marashi Al-Najafi. (in Arabic)
  28. Faiz al-Islam, Sayyid Ali Naghi (1989), Tarjome va Sharh-e Nahjol-Balāghe, Vol 1-6, Tehran: Faqih Printing and Publishing Organization.
  29. Ghalghashandi, Ahmad Ibn Ali (No date), Subh al-A`sha fi Sana’ata Insha, Vol 1 research by shams aldin mohammad, beirut: dar al-kotob al-elmiyeh. (in Arabic)
  30. Ka’abi, Abbas (2015), Interpretation of Principles of Islamic Republic of Iran System in the Light of Constitutional Principles, Vol. 1, 1st, Tehran: Guardian Council Research Institute. (in Persian)
  31. Gorji, Abolghasem (1994), "Iqtrah", Naqd Va Nazar, Winter, Vol 1, pp 14- 106. (in Persian)
  32. Giddens A, Duneier M, Appelbaum RP, Carr DS (2008), Introduction to sociology, translated by Hassan Chavoshian, 2nd, Tehran: Ney. (in Persian)
  33. Mawardi, Ali ibn Muḥammad ibn Habib (2006), Al-Ahkam Al-Sultaniya wa Al-Walayat Al-Diniya, Mecca: Abas ahmad al-baz Publication. (in Arabic)
  34. Majlisi, Muḥammad Baqir (1983), Bihar al-Anwar, vol. 44, 2nd, Qom: Al-Wafa Institute. (in Arabic)
  35. Meshkini, Ali (1969), Estelahat al-osoul, 1st, Qom: Hekmat Publications. (in Arabic)
  36. Mughnīyya, Muḥammad Jawād (1991), Elme osoule fighe fi sobah al-jadid, Qom: Dar al-Kitab al-Islami Publication. (in Arabic)
  37. Makarem Shirazi, Nasser (No date), Dorous khareje fighe, Booklet 9, Qom: Feyzieh Publishing. (in Persian)
  38. Montazeri, Hussein Ali (2008), Islamic Punishments and Human Rights, Qom: Arghavan Danesh Publication.
  39. Montazeri, Hussein Ali (2009), Islam, dine fetrat, Qom: sayeh Publishing. (in Persian)
  40. Montazeri, Hussein Ali (1988), Derasat fi valayat Al faqih wa fiqhe al daulat al Islamiya, Vol. 2, Qom: markaze jahani talime islami Organization. (in Arabic)
  41. Montazeri, Hussein Ali (2007), Derasat fi al-makaseb al-moharamah, vol. 1, Qom: arghavane danesh. (in Arabic)
  42. Montazeri, Hussein Ali (2015), Letter of Rights, Tehran: Sarayi. (in Persian)
  43. Musavi Khomeini, Sayyid Ruhollah (2010), Sahifeye Emam (Collection of Imam Khomeini (PBUH), Volumes 4 and 9, Tehran: The Institute for Compilation and Publication of Imam Khomeini's Works. (in Persian)
  44. Musavi Khomeini, Sayyid Ruhollah (2006), Al-Rasa'il, vol. 1, Qom The Institute for Compilation and Publication of Imam Khomeini's Works. (in Arabic)
  45. Naqdi, Zeynab (2017), A sociological analysis about accommodation of Homicide punishment to irainian Social Developments, Master Thesis in Criminal Law and Criminology, Mashhad: Ferdowsi University. (in Persian)
  46. ​​ Nobahar, Rahim. (2019). “Locating Criminal Teachings in Islamic Jurisprudence and its Methodological Consequences”, Journal of Law Research, 22(85), 169-194. (in Persian)
  47. Nobahar, Rahim (2013), "Research about Classification of Taziri Punishment in Islamic Penal Law", Legal Research Quarterly, Volume 16, Issue 63, pp. 254-213 (in Persian)
  48. Nobahar, Rahim (2005), "Study on Hormate Tanfir from Religion", Legal Research, Autumn and Winter, Memoirs of Dr. Shahidi No41, 171-129. (in Persian)

49 Nourpour, Mohsen., Javan Ja’afari Bojnordi, Abdolreza., Sadati, Sayyid Jawād. (2019), “The Sociological Analysis of between formal criminal policy and punitive ethics of society (Case study: The degree of attribution of public opinion in Mashhad city in severe physical punishment)”, Criminal law and Criminology Studies, 49(2), 513-541. (in Persian)

  1. Hashemi, Sayyid Muḥammad (2015), Constitutional of the Islamic Republic of Iran, Vol. 2, 28th, Tehran: Mizan Publication. (in Persian)
  2. Yazdi, Muḥammad (1989), Explanation on Islamic Republic of Iran Constitution, 1st, Tehran: Payam Publication. (in Persian)
  3. Conetti, Giorgio, Migliorino, Luigi, Scovazzi, Tullio (2006), Testi di base per lo studio del diritto internazionale, Milano: Giuffré Publication.
  4. Corte costituzionale, n. 16, 7-2-1978.
  5. Corte costituzionale, n. 22, 9-2-1981.
  6. Corte costituzionale, n. 23, 11-2-1981.
  7. Corte costituzionale, n. 28, 4-2-1993.
  8. De Marco, Eugenio (2010), Istituzioni in cammino: scritti di diritto costituzionale, Milano: Giuffré Publication.
  9. Faga, Simona (2011), “Il vincolo referendario. Analisi del rapporto tra il referendum abrogativo e la legge ordinaria”, Tesi di dottorato, Università di Ferrara.
  10. Garland, David (2012), Punishment and Social Solidarity, The SAGE Handbook of Punishment and Society, London.
  11. Garland, David (1991), “Sociological Perspectives on Punishment”, Crime and Justice, Vol. 14, 165- 115.
  12. Gigliotti, Alessandro (2009), L’ammissibilità dei referendum in materia elettorale”, Milan: Giuffré Publication.
  13. Guiducci, Pier Luigi (1999), Manuale di diritto sanitario, Milan: Franco Angeli.
  14. Iaricci, Gian Piero (2014), Istituzioni di diritto pubblico, Rimini: Maggioli.
  15. Rolla, Giancarlo (2018), “I quesiti delle consultazioni popolari. Considerazioni alla luce dell’esperienza referendaria in Italia”, Nomos, n. 1, 21.
Journal of Studies in Islamic Law & Jurisprudence
Volume 14, Issue 26
March 2022
Pages 59-92

Files

Share

How to cite

Statistics