A Critical studying of the reason of who believe in tort Liability Arising from failing to rescue another

Mirdadashi, Seyyed Mahdi; Safari, Esfandiyar

doi:10.22075/feqh.2020.17836.2053

Document Type : Original Article

Authors

¹ College of law، Private law ، Humanities ، Islamic Azad University of Qom ، Iran

² Assistant Professor, Department of Private Law, Ahlul Bayt International University, Tehran, Iran

https://doi.org/10.22075/feqh.2020.17836.2053

Abstract

In response to the question of whether relinquish rescuing Another Life would result tortious liability, there is Different views among legal writers. Believers of tort Liability have expressed four reasons: 1- fault
of the abandoner 2- leaving of the duty 3- relation between Criminal responsibility and tort liability 4- Preventing from getting the right. In this article, after explaining the viewpoints, it has proved that relinquish rescuing another life does not cause tortious liability and the conduct of the abandoner is not included to article 295 of the islamic Penal Code. In fact, leaving one's life saved is simply a matter of dignity and no guarantee.

Keywords

References

-Abne baraj, Abolaziz(1986) ,Almohazab, Vol. 2, Qom: Institute of Islamic Publishing

-Abne zooyan, Abrahim(1989) ,Narosabil Fe Sharhol Dalil, Vol. 2: Islamic Library

-Abne godame, (1978) ,Almoghni, Vol. 8: Gahere Library.

-Abne godame, (1978) ,Almoghni, Vol. 9: Gahere Library.

-Araki, Mohammad Ali (1984), Esteftaat , Qom: Maroof.

-Esfahani, Mohammad Hossein (1988), Bohoth al feghe(Lease book), Qom: Institute of Islamic Publishing

-Amiri ghaem maghami, Abdol al- Majed (1999), Obligations Law ,Vol. 1, Tehran: Mezan.

-Ansari mortaza, (2001), Faraedel Al- Osool ,Vol. 2, Qom: World Congress commemorating Sheikh Ansari.

-Bariklo, Aleraza (2014), Tort Law , Tehran: Mezan. –

- Bahooti,Mansoor (-) ,Cashfoll genahe, Vol. 6: The house of Scientific book.

- Haji Dehabadi, Ahmad (2012), “Leaving the Rescuing Another Life as a deadly act ", Legal Research, Issue.57 , pp.273-313

Hajavi,Moosa (-) ,Allegnahe, Vol. 4: , Beroot: The house of Almarefe.

Hoseni khamenei,Seyed Ali (-) , Esteftaat.

- Hosseini Shahroodi , Seyed Mohammad (1995), Esteftaat , Qom: The Ismailian Press Institute.

Hosseini Amelli, Seyed Javad (-), Meftaholl Karame , Vol. 5: , Beroot: The house of Ehyaoll Torath.

- Hosseini Maraghi , Seyed Mir Abdol al- Fatah (2004), al- Anaven,Vol. 2, Qom: Institute of Islamic Publishing

-Khosravi , Mohammad Reaza (-), Complete set of penal cod and regulations with the latest amendments 1381 , Tehran: Majd.

Shoberi Zanjani , Seyed Moosa (1999), Ketaboll Nekah,Vol. 5, Qom: Institute of Raypardaz.

- Khansari , Seyed Mohammad (2003), Formal logic , Tehran: Agah.

- Ghasemzadeh , Seyed Mortaza (1999), Principles of Tort Law , Tehran: Dadgostar.

-Sahid Sani, (1992),Masalek al- Afham,Vol. 12, Qom: Institute of Islamic Education.

-Sahid Sani, (1992),Masalek al- Afham,Vol. 15, Qom: Institute of Islamic Education.

-Safari, Esfandyar(2013), Juridical-Legal studying of Other-property Mangment(Article 306 of the Civil Code) , Mashhad: Islamic Science University of Razavi.

-Tosi, Mohammad Ebn al- Hassan (1967), Al- Mabsoot ,Vol. 6, , Tehran: Dar al-Ehya al-Jafareyeh Library.

-Allame Helli, (2000),Thriro al- Ahkam,Vol. 5, Qom: Imam Sadegh Institute.-

-Gafari Farsani, Behnam (2015), “Obligation of the Rescuing Another Life … ", Jastic, Issue.84 , pp.25-47.

- Foroghi and Partners (2015), “Juridical-Logical Analysis of Obligatory- Statutory Provisions in Action Stopping according to Cited Relation", Jurisprudential Research, Issue.45 , pp.89-112.

-Katozeyan, Naser (1999), Tort Law ,Vol. 1, Tehran: University of Tehran Publications.

-Marsavi, Alaodin(-), Alensaf , Vol. 10: , The house of Ehyaoll Torath.

- Magdasi,Abdollrahman (-) ,Alsharholl Kabir, Vol. 9: The house of Arabic book.

-Mir Mohammad Sadegi , Hossein (2014),Offences Against The Person , Tehran: Mezan.

- Njafi, Mohammad Hassan (1995), Javaher al-Kalam,Vol. 41, Tehran: Eslamiye Bookstore.

- Njafi, Mohammad Hassan (1984), Javaher al-Kalam,Vol. 43, Tehran: Eslamiye Bookstore.

-Noori,Mirza Hosseini, (1998), Mostadrakoll Vasaell , Vol. 18: , Qom, Ahllollbeyt Institute

Journal of Studies in Islamic Law & Jurisprudence

A Critical studying of the reason of who believe in tort Liability Arising from failing to rescue another

References

References

Volume 12, Issue 23
February 2021
Pages 361-388

A Critical studying of the reason of who believe in tort Liability Arising from failing to rescue another

References

References

Volume 12, Issue 23February 2021Pages 361-388

Volume 12, Issue 23
February 2021
Pages 361-388