Analysis of Impact of Crime Victims’ Consent on the Criminal and Civil Liability with a look at Iran's legislative process

Elyasinia, Abolfazl; Arefnia, Teybeh

doi:10.22075/feqh.2020.13223.1342

Document Type : Original Article

Authors

Abolfazl Elyasinia ¹
Teybeh Arefnia ²

¹ PhD Student in Islamic Jurisprudence and Fundamentals of Islamic Law, Imam Khomeini Memorial Branch, Tehran, Iran

² Assistant Professor of Jurisprudence and Fundamentals of Islamic Law, Islamic Azad University, Imam Khomeini Memorial Branch, Tehran, Iran (Corresponding Author)

https://doi.org/10.22075/feqh.2020.13223.1342

Abstract

The victim’s consent to commit a crime against himself/herself does not affect the criminal and civil liability of the offender. Because enforcing the laws and giving sentences are not to serve the individual's interests. Rather, it is for the establishment and maintenance of public order and the security of society. Therefore, due to the legal rules and legislation, victim’s satisfaction carries no legal value and validity and is not considered as a justified cause for the crime. In some cases, however, due to its benefits and social necessity and acceptance, and sometimes due to the character and nature of the crime committed, the legislator has regarded the victim's dissatisfaction as one of the essential elements that form the crime. Hence, with the victim’s consent, the criminal nature of the offense is altered, thereby it prevents the criminal and civil liability from being established. This article attempts to analyze and compare the impact of the victim's consent on criminal and civil liability for crimes against people, such as medical errors, etc. from the perspective of the legislative process and Islamic jurisdiction.

Keywords

References

- The Holy Quran

- Abdolnaser, Jamal (1970), Mawsuat fe Al-Feqh Al-eslami, Gahere: Almajles Alala Al eslami Publication

- Abolbarakaat, Ahmad Al-dardir (No date), Al-Sharol Al-Kabir, Vol.4, Beirut: Dar Al-Ehya Al-kotob-Al-Arabi

- Aghai, Jannatmakan, Hosain (2012), General Criminal Law, Vol.1, Tehran: Jangal Publication

- Aghai nia, Hosain, (1992), Sports Rights- Sport and its Legal

Responsibilities, Tehran: Tarbiat moallem University Publication

- Ahmad Alzargha (1967), Al-Madkhal Al-Feqhi Al-am, Vol.1, Damesh: Dar Al-Fekr Publication

- Aliabadi, abdolhosain (1989), Criminal law, Vol.1, Tehran: Ferdusi Publication

- Ameli Javad ibn mohammad hosaini (1999), Meftah Al-Kerama fi Sharhe Ghavaed Al-Allama, Vol.15-12, Beirut: Dar Al-Ehya Al-Toras-Al-Arabi

- Ameli (sheed sani), Zain Aldin ibn ali (1983), Al-Rawzah Al-Bahiyah fi Sharah Al-Lomaah Al-Demashqaiyah, Vol.10, Beirut: Dar Al-Ehya Al-Toras-Al-Arabi

-Ameli (sheed sani), Zain Aldin ibn ali (1993), Masalel Al-afham ela Tamgheeh sharae Al- eslam, Vol.15, Qom: Almaaref Al-eslami Publication

- Ardebili, Ahmad (1983), Majma Al-faeda va Al- borhan fi sharh ershad Al- azhan, Vol.8, Qom: Islamic Publication

- Ardebili, Mohammad ali (2016), General Criminal Law, Vol.1, Tehran: Mizan Publication

- Aryanpur Kashani, Abbas ana Manochehr (1998), English - Persian pocket dictionary, Vol.2, Tehran: Amirkabir Publication

- Baghdadi, Abomohammad (No date), Majma Al-Zamanat, Vol.1, Tehran: Dar Al-Kotob Al- Eslamiye Publication

- Baheri. Mohammad (2002), General Criminal Law, Tehran: Roham Publication

- Dehkhoda, Aliakbar (1957), Dictionary, Vol.5, Tehran: Tehran University Publication

- Feiz Kashani, Mohammad Mohsen (1981), Mafateeh Al- sharaye, Vol.2, Qom: Najafi marashi Publication

- Goldouzian, Iraj (2007), The Requirements of Genrral Criminal Law, Tehran: Mizan Publication

- Goldouzian, Iraj (2011), Special Criminal Law, Offences Against, Persons, Property, Security of The State and Public Tranquility, Tehran: Tehran University Publication

- Goldouzian, Iraj (2007) General Criminal Law,Vol.1, Tehran: Tehran University Publication

-Goldouzian, Iraj (2007) , principles of General Criminal Law, Tehran: Mizan Publication

- Hakim,(Tabatabai), Mohsen (2012), Mostamsak Al-orva Al-vosgha, Vol.12, Beirut: Dar Al-Ehya Al-Toras-Arabi

- Helli, Najm Al-Din Jafar Ibn Hasasn (2005), Sh’aria al-Islam, Vol.4, Beirut: Dar al-Ghari Institute

- Helli, (Fakhr A -Mohagheghin), Mohammad Ibn Hasan Ibn Yoosof (1973), Ezah Al-favaed fi sharh moshkelat Al-ghavaed, Vol.4. Qom: Esmaelian Publications

- Hosseini Maraghi, Abdolfattah (1998), Al-anaain Al- feghhee, Qom: Society of Islamic Publications

- Ibn Edris Helli, Mohammad Ibn Mansoor (1990), Al-Saraer Al-Havi le-Tahrir-el- Fatawi, Vol.3, Qom :Islamic Poblication Office

- Ibn ghodameh, Abdollah ibn Ahmad (1984), Almoghni va Al-Sharh Al-Kabir , Vol .6 , Beirut: Dar al-Ehya al-Toras-Arabi

- Ibn Roshd, Abolvalid (2005), Bedayat Al-Mojtahed va Nahayat Al- Moghtased, Vol.2, Ghahere: Dar Al-Hadice Publication

- Jafari Langroodi,Mohammad Jafar (2116), Law Terminology, Tehran: Ganje Danesh Bookstore

- Kasani, Alaoddin (1997), Badae Al-Sanae fi Tartib Al- Sharaee, Vol.7, Beirut: Dar Al- Kotob Al- Elmieh

- katoziyan, Naser (2000), Civil Law. Civil rights, legal acts, contracts and indictments , Foundation course , Tehran: Publishing Joint Stock Company

- Lankarani, Mohammad fazel movahhedi (2004), Al- Ahkam Al-Vazeha, Qom: Aemmah Athar Fiqh Center

- Masjed Sarai (2014), A New Approach to the Causes of Physician Civil Liability, Journal of Jurisprudence and Islamic Law, Issue.10, pp 169-190

- Mir Mohammad Sadeghi, Hosain (2015), Offences Against Property, Vol. 2, Tehran: Mizan Legal Foundation

-Mir Mohammad Sadeghi, Hosain (2016), Offences Against Persons, Vol. 1, Tehran: Mizan Legal Foundation

- Mir Saeedi, Mansour (2004), Criminal responsibility and its scope and elements, Vol.1, Tehran: Mizan Publication

- Mohaghegh Damad,Seyed Mostafa (2004),Rulse of Jurrisprudence in Civil Division, Tehran: Center of Publication Islamic Sciences

- Mousavi (Golpayegani), Mohammad reza (1993), Hedayat Al-ebad, Vol.1, Qom: Dar Al- Quran Publication

- Mousavi, Imam Khomeini, Rouhollah (2004), Tahrir-Al-Vasileh, Vol.4, Qom: Islamic Publication Institute

-Mousavi, Imam Khomeini, Rouhollah (1984), Zobdah Al-Ahkam, Tehran, Publishing organization of Islamic propagation

- Mousavi, Khoyi, Seyyed Abolghasem (2002), Principles of Takmalah Al-Menhaj, Vol.2, Qom: Asar Al-Khoyi Institute

- Najafi (Saheb Javaher), Mohammad Hasan (1984), Javaher al-Kaalam Fi Sharh al Sh’aria Al-Islam,Vol.42, Beirut: Dar al-Ehya al-Toras-Arabi

- Nejati, Mahdi (2010), Physician's responsibility in the jurisprudence and criminal law of Iran , Tehran: khursandi Publication

- Nourbaha, reza (2008), Context of General Criminal Law, Tehran: Ghanj Danesh Publication

- Novi, Mohi aldin (No date), Rawzah Al-talEbine , Vol.3, Beirut: Dar Al-kotob Alelmiyeh Publication

- Pad, Ebrahim, (2002), Special Criminal Law, Vol.1, Roham Publication

- Roostai, Mohsen (1993), Wagan Justice is The Founder of Iran, Vol.1, Tehran: Historical investigations Magazine

- Sabzevari, Mohammad Bagher (2003), Kefayat Al- Ahkam Al-Halal, Vol.1, Qom: Islamic Publication

- Sadeghi, Mohammad Hadi (2003), "Satisfaction with crime, Journal of modrres". Issue. 1, pp. 57-71

- Sadough, Mohammad Ibn Ali (1982), Man la yahzaroh Al- fagheh, Vol.4, Beirut: Dar Al-Sab Va Dar Al-Taarof Publication

- Safai, Hossain (2012), "The basis of a physician's civil liability With Looking at the new bill of the Islamic Penal Code", Journal of Scientific buffers for judicial law views Issue.58, p152

- Sanei, Parviz (2004) General Criminal Law, Tehran: Ghanj Danesh Publication

- Shambayati, Houshang (2003), General Criminal Law ,Vol.1, Tehran: Amjad and Zubin Publication

-Shambayati, Houshang (1996), General Criminal Law ,Vol.2, Tehran: Amjad and Zubin Publication

- Sharbini. Mohammad Khateeb (No date), Moghni almohtaj, Vol.4, Beirut: Dar Al-Fekr Publication

- Sistani, Ali Hosaini (2002), Al-masael Al-montakhabah, Qom: The office of Hazrat Ayat Allah Sistani Publication

-Sistani, Ali Hosaini (1997), Menhaj Al-salehin, Vol.2, Qom: The office of Hazrat Ayat Allah Sistani Publication

- Soyooti, Jlaloddin Abdolraahman Ibn Abibakr (1983), Al-Ashbah Va Al-Nazayir fI Al-Ghawaeid Va Al- Furue Fegh Al-Shafeieye, Beirut: Dar Al-Kotob Al-Elmieh Publication

- Tabatabaei, Ali (1984), Reyaz Al- masael, Vol.2, Qom: Alo Al-Bayt Institute

- Tbrizi, Javad (2008), Tangheeh Mabani Al-ahkam, Ketab Al-diyat, Qom: Dar Al-Seddigha (p.b) Publication

- Touri, Mohammad Ibn Hossain (1982), Takamleh Al-bahr Al-raiqh fi sharah kanz Al-daqhaiqh, Vol.2, Beirut: Dar Al-Kotob Al-Elmieh Publication

- Tousi, Aboujafar Mohammad Ibn Hasan (2000), Al- Khelaf, Vol.5, Qom:Nashr Eslami Publication

- Validi, Mohammad Saleh (2001), Special Criminal Law ,Vol.2 , Tehran: Dad Institute

- Validi, Mohammad Saleh(1993), General Criminal Law ,Vol.2 , Tehran: Dad Institute

- Zainodin Ibn Ali Alameli (1999), Msalek Al-Afham Ela Tangheyh Sharaye Al-Islam, Vol.15, Qom: Islamic Knowledge Publication

Journal of Studies in Islamic Law & Jurisprudence

Analysis of Impact of Crime Victims’ Consent on the Criminal and Civil Liability with a look at Iran's legislative process

References

References

Volume 12, Issue 23
February 2021
Pages 67-96

Analysis of Impact of Crime Victims’ Consent on the Criminal and Civil Liability with a look at Iran's legislative process

References

References

Volume 12, Issue 23February 2021Pages 67-96

Volume 12, Issue 23
February 2021
Pages 67-96