Distinguishing the Nullity of Discharging Judgment of the Lessee Subject to Lessor and Lessee Relations Act 1977

Document Type : Original Article

Authors

1 Professor of Shahiid Chamran University- Ahvaz,

2 Associate Professor of Semnan University

Abstract

According to section 28 of lessor and lessee relations Act 1977, there are some deadlines for goodwill payment to the lessee subject to discharging judgment or the request of issuing discharging executive order (in the case the judgment, does not include  good will payment to the lessee). Moreover it declares that non-observance of specified deadlines by lessor, will result in nullity of the judgment. The nullity of such discharging judgment which takes place without being disapproved by the court and prevents from the disconnection of tenancy, is unclear in many aspects. Its conception, conditions and executive procedures are not clear in the Act. Also Jurisprudence and doctrine have no clear records in this regards. It appears that the result depends on whether the discharging judgment includes the Goodwill payment or not. Anyway, non- payment of such a right by the lessor in time or the request of applying discharging order, is the legal condition of nullity of the judgment but there is no specific procedure in the Act for such a case. It seems that the nullity, takes place automatically and without any court's decision.

Keywords

References

- Ahmadi, Nee'mat (1993), the Study of Lessor and Lessee Acts, Tehran: Atlas.
 
- Jaa'fari Langroudi (1997), Legal Encyclopedia, Vol 3, Tehran, Amir kabir
- Hosseini, Seyyed Mohammad Reza (2008), Lessor and Lessee Relations Acts of 1977 and 1997 in Jurisprudence, Tehran, Negah Bayyeneh.
- Helli (Allameh), Hassan Ibn Yousof (1993), Ghavaed Al-Ahkam, Vol 3, Qom: Al-Nashr Al-Eslami Institution.
- Hayati, Ali Abbas (2011), Civil Judgments Execution in Present Legal Order, Tehran: Mizan.
- Hayati, Ali Abbas (2011), Civil Procedure in Present Legal Order, Tehran: Mizan.
- Khomeini (Imam) Seyyed Rouh Allah, Tahrir Al-Vasileh, Vol 2, Qom: Esmaielyan Institution.
- Zeinali, Mehdi (2011), Good will and Right of Business and Trade, Tehran: Jangal.
Sivari Helli, Megdad Ibn Abd-Allah (1985), Al- tanghih Al- Rree' Le- Mokhtasar Al-Sharayee', Vol 2, Qom.
- Shams, Abd- Allah (2002), Civil Procedure, Vol 2, Tehran: Mizan
- Shamsi Pour, Gholam Reza (2009), The Study of Acts and Affaires Relating to Good will and Right of Business and Trade, Tehran: Boka.
- Shahri, Gholam Reza; Kharrazi, Mohammad (2001), the Complex of Advisory Opinions of Legal and Judiciary Codification General Direction in Civil Affairs, Tehran, Official Journal Publications.
- Fallah, Mohammad Reza (2009), Proof in Lessor and Lessee Relations Act 1977T Vol 2, Tehran, Jangal- Javdaneh
- Feiz Kashani, Mohammad Mohsen (1981), Mafatih Al- Sharayee', Vol 3, Qom.
- Katouzian, Nasser (2008), Civil Law (Lessons on Nominated Contracts), Vol 1, Tehran, Ganj Danesh.
- Keshavarz, Bahman (2003), Good will and Right of Business and Trade in Iranian and Eslamic Law, Tehran: Keshavarz.
- Lotfi, Asad- Allah (2012), Jurisprudential and Legal Subjects of Lease Contract, Tehran: Jangal
- Mohammadi, Pezhman (2015), the Position of Lessor and Lessee Relations Act approved 1976 in Iranian Legal System, Ahwaz: Shahid Chamran University.
- Mardani, Nader; Ghahreman, Mohammad (2011), the Execution of Civil Judgments and Foreign Enforceable Judgments and Documents in Iran, Tehran: Mizan.
- Vice – Educational of Judiciary (2008), Iranian Jurisprudence in Relation to Public Legal Courts, Tehran: Jangal.
- Vice – Educational of Judiciary (2008), Judicial Disagreements in Civil Act subjects, Tehran, Ghaza.
- Noo'bakht, Yousef (1993, Legal Ideas, Tehran, Keyhan.
- Nahreiny, Fereydoun (2013), Discontinuance of Execution of Court Judgment, Tehran: Ganj Danesh.
- Yousef Zadeh (Morteza (2011), Civil Law (Nominated Contracts), Tehran: Sherkat Sahami Enteshar.  
Journal of Studies in Islamic Law & Jurisprudence
Volume 11, Issue 20
June 2019
Pages 325-350

Files

Share

How to cite

Statistics